The Departed
The Prestige
Casino Royale
Flags of Our Fathers
Now, I really liked The Departed and Casino Royale, but I absolutely HATED The Prestige and Flags. My percentage used to be so much higher than 50% positive. Both movies that I could not stand have been getting decent reviews and people that I know and (for the most part) respect their opinions about movies liked both.
So, that got me to thinking... is the act of seeing a movie at the theater sullying my experience? Or were the movies just bad and everyone else is stupid? We all have our opinions, so I can't give an iron clad answer, but right now I'm going for the second one.
There were no real disturbances in the theater when I saw The Prestige, and I really wanted to like it, having loved Nolan's earlier movies. And I did, up until about the last 45 minutes. At that point in the movie I can just imagine the writers table whence they were constructing this pile of crap:
[SPOILER]
"Oh noes! I've constructed this engaging plot but have no way of getting out of it cleanly."
"I know! Clones! Yeah, let's have clones all up in this piece."
"AWESOME. AWESOME TO THE MAX. And then we can end the movie without explaining anything, so that people have discussions about what happened, which will make them think they liked it because it was a mind bender."
[/SPOILER]
As for Flags, I did have a bevy of jickwad assfaces around me putting their feet on MY row and commenting on the movie, but even if I had been alone in the theater, that movie still would have sucked. Let us count the ways:
- Incredibly bad acting for such a big budget/acclaimed movie, and as a result I felt no connection to any of the characters and could care less if/when they died. Ryan Phillipe was the medic in this movie, and more or less the main character, but Giovanni Ribissi (sp?) was so much better in that role in Saving Private Ryan.
- The war scenes were edited terribly. They showed the same shot over and over and over again, and it wasn't even a cool shot.
- Tear jerking moments that would fail to draw a tear from anyone except people who were actually on Iwojima. I've never seen so many attempts at an emotional moment fall so flat. At least Titanic did that right.
- And their main foul up was the gross misuse of Barry Pepper in a WWII movie. I'm sure there's a rule somewhere stating that whether or not he dies, he should be the coolest character in the movie.
Maybe a little Tony Scott seizure material will right the ship. Anyone up for Deja Vu?